Main Content

Apple Butter

Thomas has been delivering delicious McCutcheon’s apple butter to his farm areas for over 27 years. It’s been great to be identified as “the Apple Butter guy!” As a way to bring folks together, Selena Robleto organized an “Apple Butter Cookoff” back in 2019. And in the summer of 2020, the second contest was held at the Flower Valley Pool on Saturday, August 20th. Folks were happy to see this event return after a two-year hiatus for COVID.
Apple Butter Jar
Team PhotoWinners for this year’s Contest:
  • 1st place – John/Layla: Apple Butter Brie Bites
  • 2nd place – Kate: Apple Butter Cake Pops
  • 3rd place – Aya: Apple Butter Cupcakes with Pumpkin Buttercream Frosting
  • Kids Award: Apple Butter Pie
As a way to give you all some ideas on how to use this season’s jar – coming to you SOON – here are some recipes to tempt you into your kitchens!
Apple Butter Cake with Brown Sugar Buttercream courtesy of
Oatmeal Apple Butter Bars courtesy of
Apple Butter Snickerdoodles courtesy of
Slow Cooker Apple Butter Pulled Pork courtesy of
Spiced Cran-Apple Brisket courtesy of
Apple Butter, Pepper Jack & Croissant Grilled Cheese courtesy of
Skip to content